Reified and Refined

  1. Search
  2. About
  3. Ask me anything
  4. Subscribe
  5. Archive
  6. Random

Reified and Refined

Library & Info Science student and community technologist. Hustler of culture. Urbana, IL.

Newer
Older
  • Wikipedia's Missing Women

    The whole thing is fucked up and sad in general, but this bit in particular leaped out at me.

    “It is ironic,” he said, “because I like these things — freedom, openness, egalitarian ideas — but I think to some extent they are compounding and hiding problems you might find in the real world.”

    Adopting openness means being “open to very difficult, high-conflict people, even misogynists,” he said, “so you have to have a huge argument about whether there is the problem.” Mr. Reagle is also the author of “Good Faith Collaboration: The Culture of Wikipedia.”

    Generously, this is the Geek Social Fallacy at its worst. Less generously, it gives away the game on any nominal lip service we give to gender equality in online culture, and has little to distinguish it from pathetic wingnut tu quoque “arguments” that oh-so-cleverly point out that our precious tolerance doesn’t extend to the very sort of intolerant and antisocial behavior that negates it, so of course it’s no tolerance at all.

    That Wikipedia could get this far along without examining those sorts of undergrad maladroit geekboy assumptions is troubling to say the least.

    Posted on January 31, 2011 with 1 note

    1. lastyearsfad reblogged this from jddunn and added:
      I’m on a lot of shit online, but I’m definitely not a wikipedia mod.
    2. jddunn posted this
  • thekidshouldseethis
  • nypl
  • vastmachinery
  • libraryland
  • oldtobegin
  • iena
  • kathrynyu
  • lowindustrial
  • andrewtsks
  • jennfrank
  • shitmystudentswrite
  • bookconfessions
  • fullmst3k
  • eyeonspringfield
  • awol
  • moviesimpsons
  • maura
  • thingsorganizedneatly
  • n-a-s-a
  • sooz
  • perpetua
  • apartness
  • oneweekoneband
  • shooshee
  • citationneeded
  • me3dia
  • hunk-o-mass
  • liberalsarecool
  • preservearchives
  • librarianista
  • jackflaps
  • icouldmakethat
  • thatsonpoint
  • the-feature
  • tymn
  • slaughterhouse90210
  • livelymorgue
  • pbsthisdayinhistory
  • leitch
  • bluishorange
  • fidius
  • bustr
  • dayan
  • kimjongillookingatthings
  • johnvanderslice
  • lastyearsfad
  • catalogliving
  • thecomposites
  • nancylicious
  • dostoyevsky
  • russkayaliteratura
  • uglyrenaissancebabies
  • mattie
  • librarianwardrobe
  • unhappyhipsters
  • livingluster
  • holajupiter
  • ernie
  • dictionaryofobscuresorrows
  • ursamajor
  • anil
  • runofplay
  • kfan
  • shitty
  • meghanagain
  • pooryorickentertainment
  • zebraradar
  • mongoliansummer
  • annakovsky
  • gilbs3
  • theminjungkim
  • historicalmeetups
  • teenageart
  • thatsnotonline
  • placeblogger
  • tripticks
  • wockerjabby
  • creepyrobots
  • hello
  • letterheady
  • future-drama
  • fuckyeahinfo
  • pre-durst
  • iwdrm
  • crushingkrisis
  • maljal
  • fuckyeahthemountaingoats
  • textsfrompawnee
  • april-is
  • gordonwithers
  • colinthelibrarian
  • kidsbooks
  • lucilleandmitt
  • whereareyoureading
  • fuckyeahphilosophy
  • portiareads
  • fuckyeahtheuniverse
  • bumontheplush
  • chadgarland
  • snippid
  • yelpingwithcormac
  • fuckyeahwizardpeople
  • lookslikealever
  • nwsdiscussions
  • taylorkeith
  • ivanaskwith
  • bubblebathosbands
  • whiskeygunsandhorses
  • hateyourchildhood
  • jennkloc
  • fuckyeahgba
  • sixfoot6
  • raptorsandliterature
  • prettylush
  • keggersofyore
  • mbkutz
  • libraries
  • accessmaincomputerfile
  • godzillahaiku
  • fuckthatchicken
  • mostycatz
  • zacfromiowa
  • karinaanglada
  • assumerguide
  • garic97
  • k5test
  • isthistheendof
  • themantle
  • snakedoctor
  • quarterl1fe
  • onepersontrendstories
  • shantelhansen
  • ckompare
  • shittybooks
  • dmx
  • timeghost

Field Notes Theme. Designed by Manasto Jones. Powered by Tumblr.